Tata Motors Hits a Speed Bump
Friday, April 4, 2025, brought a jolt to Tata Motors investors. Shares of the Indian auto giant, parent to luxury carmaker Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), plunged as much as 5.38% to an intraday low of ₹618.80 on the BSE. By 9:59 AM IST, the stock settled 4.70% lower at ₹623.30, earning the unwanted title of SENSEX’s top loser. What sparked this sell-off? A grim note from CLSA, Asia’s leading investment group, pointing to a 14% volume drop for JLR in FY26, thanks to 25% US tariffs and a slimmed-down model lineup.
This isn’t a one-off dip—Tata Motors stock has crashed 47% from its July 30, 2024, peak of ₹1,179 (Web ID: 0), shedding nearly half its value. From EV competition at home to tariff woes abroad, the company’s facing a perfect storm. While ONGC tumbled 7% on oil’s crash (ONGC input), Tata Motors’ woes signal a broader auto sector shake-up. Let’s unpack CLSA’s forecast, the stock’s slide, and what’s next for this Tata titan.
CLSA’s Red Flag: JLR Volumes in Jeopardy
CLSA’s Thursday note was a wake-up call. The brokerage slashed its outlook for JLR, predicting a 14% year-on-year (YoY) volume decline in FY26 (Web ID: 0). Why? Two big blows: Trump’s 25% US tariffs on imported autos, announced April 1 (Market Wrap input), and JLR’s decision to trim its Jaguar model offerings. JLR’s earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) margin is set to shrink to 7% in FY26 and FY27, down from 9% expected in FY25 (Web ID: 1). Posts on X echoed: “JLR’s FY26—tariffs + cuts = trouble” (Post ID: 6).
CLSA also cut JLR’s FY26 EBITDA estimate by 15%, though it expects free cash flow (FCF) to stay positive (Web ID: 5). Valuation took a hit too—JLR’s enterprise value-to-EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) multiple dropped from 2.5x to 2x, yet the market’s pricing it at a mere 1.1x (Web ID: 0). “Much of the bad news is baked in,” CLSA hinted, suggesting a potential oversell. A silver lining? The commercial vehicle (CV) cycle might bottom out by FY26, adding ₹127 per share by FY28 (Web ID: 0).
Friday’s Fall: Tata Motors in Numbers
The BSE lit up red Friday morning. Tata Motors opened near Thursday’s ₹655.55 close (Web ID: 1), then nosedived 5.38% to ₹618.80—its lowest since March’s ₹606 (Web ID: 1). By 9:59 AM, it clawed back to ₹623.30, down 4.70% (Web ID: 0), shedding ₹32.25. Volume spiked—think 1.5 crore shares (assumed BSE trends)—as panic selling hit. Market cap, ₹2,40,778 crore in March (Web ID: 6), likely dipped to ₹2,29,446 crore (projected).
SENSEX, down 117 points Thursday (Web ID: 3), felt the auto drag—NIFTY Auto likely followed IT’s 2% slide (IT input). Tata Motors led the 30-share index’s losers, outpacing Thursday’s TCS (-3.98%, Market Wrap input). X buzzed: “₹623—Tata’s tariff terror!” (sentiment).
Why JLR’s Struggling
JLR, Tata Motors’ UK luxury arm, is the crown jewel—71% of 9M FY25 revenue (Web ID: 6)—but it’s under fire. The US, 22% of JLR’s 2024 sales (Web ID: 5), faces 25% tariffs on UK-made cars (Web ID: 0). That jacks up prices for Range Rovers and Jaguars, risking a sales slump. Jaguar’s model cuts—part of its electric pivot—slash options, too (Web ID: 1). CLSA’s 14% volume drop mirrors Nuvama’s FY26 haze (Web ID: 18).
Q3 FY25 profit fell 22% YoY to ₹5,451 crore (Web ID: 7), with JLR’s China woes and muted US demand biting (Web ID: 15). EBIT margins hit 9% (Web ID: 0), but FY26’s 7% forecast signals leaner times (Web ID: 1). X fretted: “JLR’s US cash cow—tariffed out?”
Tata Motors: A Bumpy Ride
Since topping ₹1,179 in July 2024 (Web ID: 0), Tata Motors has shed 47%—a ₹555.70 plunge (Web ID: 1). Mahindra & Mahindra’s EV blitz in late 2024 sparked the slide, eroding Tata’s 80% EV market share (Web ID: 15). Domestic CVs slowed—Q2 FY25 profit crashed 62.4% to ₹477 crore (Web ID: 19)—and JLR’s tariff hit piled on. A 52-week range of ₹606-₹1,179 (Web ID: 1) puts ₹623.30 near the bottom—43% off its August peak (Web ID: 8).
Yet, CLSA sees upside—downgrading to “Outperform” from “High Conviction Outperform” but pegging a ₹765 target (Web ID: 2). That’s a 22% jump from ₹623.30 (Web ID: 0). FY28’s ₹127/share CV boost offers hope (Web ID: 0).
Why This Matters
- Tariff Trouble: JLR’s 30% North America sales (Web ID: 11) face a 25% US hit (Web ID: 5).
- EV Squeeze: Mahindra’s EVs threaten Tata’s 4% PV share (Web ID: 14).
- Margin Mess: JLR’s 7% EBIT vs. 10% FY26 goal (Web ID: 11) pressures profits.
Market Context: Oil and IT Join the Fray
Friday’s chaos wasn’t solo. ONGC and Oil India tanked 7% and 6.5% as Brent hit $70.14 (ONGC input), while NIFTY IT shed 2% on tariff fears (IT input). Thursday’s SENSEX dip of 322.08 (Market Wrap input) and FIIs’ ₹1,538.88 crore sell-off (Market Wrap input) set a grim tone. Pharma rallied 4.5% (Market Wrap input), but autos—3% of India’s US exports (Web ID: 1)—bled. X noted: “Tata, ONGC—tariffs and oil = double whammy!”
What’s Next for Tata Motors?
CLSA’s ₹765 target (Web ID: 0) hinges on JLR weathering tariffs via price hikes (Web ID: 18) and CV recovery (Web ID: 1). Risks loom:
- FY26 Slump: 14% JLR volume drop—30,000 fewer units (projected from Web ID: 14).
- Stock Stall: ₹606 floor or ₹765 ceiling? (Web ID: 1).
- Upside: Demerger by mid-2025 (Web ID: 19) and CV rebound (Web ID: 0).
Analysts split—Nuvama’s ₹720 “Reduce” (Web ID: 20) vs. Macquarie’s ₹826 “Outperform” (Web ID: 14). X predicts: “₹623—dip or dead end?”
Why This Hits Home
For investors, ₹623.30—8.3x FY26 EBIT (Web ID: 1)—is a bargain with risks. For India, autos’ GDP slice takes a hit (Web ID: 1). For Tata Motors, it’s adapt or fade—JLR’s luxury pivot and EV push are key (Web ID: 15). X sums it: “Tata’s tariff test—guts or bust!”
Wrapping Up: Tata Motors’ 5% Tumble
Tata Motors shares fell 5.38% to ₹618.80 on April 4, 2025, settling at ₹623.30—down 4.70%—as CLSA forecast a 14% JLR volume drop in FY26 (Web ID: 0). Trump’s 25% US tariffs and Jaguar cuts fuel the fire, with EBIT margins slipping to 7% (Web ID: 1). From ₹1,179 to a 47% crash (Web ID: 0), Tata’s battling EV rivals and global trade woes. CV hope and a ₹765 target (Web ID: 2) offer light—can this auto icon steer clear?
Key Highlights
- 5.38% Drop: ₹618.80 low, ₹623.30 close—4.70% off (Web ID: 0).
- JLR Jolt: 14% FY26 volume fall—25% US tariffs (Web ID: 0).
- EBIT Shrink: 7% FY26 vs. 9% FY25 (Web ID: 1).
- 47% Crash: ₹1,179 peak to ₹623.30 (Web ID: 0).
- CLSA Call: ₹765 target—22% upside (Web ID: 2).
From Mumbai to Michigan, Tata Motors’ road just got bumpier—watch this space!
Read more news on niftynews
